top of page
Search

MATERIAL ACQUISITION AND POSSESSION: THE IMPACT ON HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS AND CULTURE

Writer: adam nelson
adam nelson
Dec 7, 2022
9 min read

Material Acquisition and Possession: The Impact on Human Consciousness and Culture

When we begin to think about class struggle we see throughout the world today it does not take long to think of social theorists such as Marx or Weber, and on a fictional level, writers such as Orwell or Huxley. These writers and theorists force us to wonder what it is that drives humans into situations of either great success, or utter despair. A focus of this success resides in our drive to acquire something better or to have more of something than our neighbor. This in turn projects a status level that probably means more to the person showing off their status than the person that is observing. Does this influence the neighbor’s strive to have those things that he or she doesn’t yet, or does having nicer material objects give them the belief that they are now a higher status, even though they once looked up to someone else and then strove to accomplish something similar or better? This is a highly discussed and debated topic throughout anthropology and sociology. When you read Marx, you get a sense that he had a bit of an agenda that pursued a Utopian society of sorts in the near future, and that according to his writings we were supposed to do that by becoming a more inclusive society with strong workers parties. With some past and current examples, I hope to show where we are as a society regarding a more wholesome and inclusive society while highlighting some of the theories and research that have contributed to our understanding the role acquisition and possession play when it comes to influencing social change.

The Conflict of Acquisition

Though it may seem like societies are being torn apart and that class warfare is still raging as it has been since the dawn of agriculture and civilization, we are actually now closer to achieving Marx’s view of a utopian, all-inclusive society than ever before thanks to new forms of communication and research to support it. Though we have not quite made it there yet, we have some very important information from both past and current sociologists and anthropologists that support Marx’s theory that a society progresses through class conflict between the workers and the business owners, which if we look around, still rings true today. Woodward (1979) gives examples of how role acquisition plays a part in our relations with works of art and the process of going from the role of acquisitor to the role of possessing. Another way of discussing the role that acquisition plays in society is described by Apodaca (1977) in which she shows a connection between inequalities during the sixties and seventies in the United States and with it the rise of demand for equal rights, better education, jobs, and wages from the perspective of Chicanos, referred to here as those Mexican American’s born and living in the United States of Mexican parentage. These and other works show a big difference in the way societies and differing cultures perceive ownership and possession and while we will focus on the difference between capitalist and socialist societies, we must note that not all cultures even have an idea for those two economic structures. Wang (1974) states a familiar trait of academic studies is the quest for certainty and intellectual security and the power from it, and that Marxism is neither a priori nor certain in the artificial academic sense. This is also where we are given an example of attitude toward where one finds themselves within society. Here, Wang (1974 pp. 301-302) states:

“The social mechanism which produces this attitude is undoubtedly rather complex. For those who are relatively comfortable, it is natural to resist change and to think of the society they live in as, in its basic features, a more or less permanent thing. It is to the advantage of the dominant class to encourage this conservative attitude. When too many irrational features arise in a society, one resorts to mystification and deception so that, instead of serious realistic literature, we grow up with fairy tales of many different kinds.”

Within societies around the world, we see all types of structures in the forms of institutions such as religious groups, different working classes, and political affiliations. We classify these with the hope of understanding human nature and what it is that drives not only a person but a culture or society. We can look throughout modern human history at risen and fallen civilizations and class structure and struggle, while also appealing to the idea that even though things are not always shone in a positive light, that the human race, with communication and understanding, is on a quickened path now more than ever of achieving a society that works for the people, instead of the people working as slaves for corporate entities that consider the individual just another number or another pawn to do their bidding.

Cyclical Class Conflict

Weber (1922 pp. 76) points out that “class struggle begins when possession equals the fate of the individual”. Broken down further, when we look at his views of possession as a driver of societal change, he states that there was no real struggle from the top. I have to give credit where credit is due, however, and make a quick argument to Weber’s statement that “there is no class war because workers don’t cause bankers to suffer”, when indeed in societies around the world we do see change caused from protests and strikes. What Weber is getting at here is that those at the top of the class or political spectrum are never in conflict because they don’t have to worry about the issues that the working class are typically focused on such as paying the bills or deciding which bill to pay at that time. Those ‘bankers’ described by Weber are typically in a position where they do not even give a second thought to the struggle of paying said bill, whereas the working class can think of nothing else. This also shows a level of worry and describes a stressor that those at the top never even have to consider because they have the money to take care of the issue at hand and typically have someone that handles those issues for them, be it an accountant or a legal professional as a couple of examples. Putting all of this together, according to Weber there can be no class war because only one side, the working class, are putting up a fight or protest while the others, the proletariat, are oblivious to the idea that there is a conflict or struggle at all. This disconnect has helped fuel social changes that I have witnessed through the media in my lifetime such as the Arab Spring or the socialist wave currently pushing through the United States political scene that is seeking universal healthcare and tuition free college amongst other things that would significantly relieve some of the burden of paying to have a better life than the majority of the working class has typically had.

This is a circle of conflict in a way because the argument can be made that there can be class warfare due to strikes and protests in societies with the freedoms to practice civil disobedience, though at what cost to the worker before achieving their end goal; be it better working conditions, higher wages, or free healthcare. Weber also states that social order is conditioned by the economic order and in turn the social order reacts upon it thus influencing the economic order. By this he makes my above argument for me by believing that the lower class can influence the economic order, and even though he was not a Marxist that believed in a communist utopia, most of his views align with the way I view the world in trying to understand how the intentions of the landowners and the intentions of the working class are similar, yet so far apart when it comes to creating a more inclusive, egalitarian society. In Weber (1922) his argument regarding the “creditor-debtor relation becoming the basis of class situations” really stuck out to me because I have worked as a debt collector and collected on billings for credit cards, unpaid trucking invoices, and taxes. I can say some of the things I witnessed really made me begin to take into question the relationship between creditors and debtors. Setting aside the typical argument of predatory lending being an issue within many societies which I witnessed firsthand, we must look at the larger scope of the problem. That problem begins with those whom control the laws behind these lending practices which can come back around to Weber’s statement that there is no class warfare because those at the top basically have nothing to worry about.

Lobbying has been a thing, I would argue, since the beginning of agriculture and maybe even before that, though it may be deemed as bartering or back-door dealing. I witnessed and was written up for not conforming to an idea that I needed to get my customers to sign a petition that would stop a cap on interest rates being proposed in the form of legislation in the United States Congress. The owners directly influenced the working class to make a decision that was not in their best interest in order to get the money that they needed at that immediate moment. Zukerfeld (2017 p.162) summarizes this conflict in great style, “We should point out that our intervention is not accidental. It emerges from a period in which the notion of class and, indeed, the idea of social strata, have been blurred in the social sciences and humanities.” I saw a clear ethical issue taking advantage of the working and lower class by a company that charged 547.55% Annual Percentage Rate on a thirty-day pay-day loan, so I intervened in a way that was not appreciated. I left the company about a month later. This example shines a light on so many things about current class struggle. I was a working-class citizen, taking advantage of other working-class citizens and when I would need to get a loan approval, I would at times literally be calling a higher up while they were on the golf course. The conflict between classes in my own view had never been clearer, which opened a world of questions regarding things discussed by some of the greatest theorists of modern history from ideas about workers’ rights to an even larger spectrum of civil rights which was; why are we still treating others that are only trying to get ahead as if they are the burden of society and the only reason ‘bad’ policy exists.


Bias and Misunderstanding

Apodaca (1977 p.71) wrote about the Chicano and Mexican Americans of the southwestern United States, relating there experience to working class struggle on a broader spectrum throughout other cultures around the world. One of the statements made in her work really stood out to me. She explained that even though in some historiographies Chicanas are shown in pictures of passivity, naiveness, and weakness, which Apodaca describes in a word as “femininity” and describes this as the typical Mexican conception of what a woman’s role should be. Apodaca states:

“The history of Mexico and the United States show us that the only women who could enjoy femininity, gentleness, and little or no work, as those were the women of the property-owning class. For the women of the laboring classes, including the majority of Chicanas and Mexicanas, their class situation has meant working in the fields, in factories, as well as at cooking, washing, and sewing. For working- class women and for Chicanas, work was not a choice but a necessity”.

My question after reading this is how we keep seeing things such as discrimination, alienation, and sexism still running rampant in western society when we have been documenting that it is happening for so long. At what point do we say enough is enough and look to the ideas of how to achieve the utopian society described by Marx and others nearly two centuries ago?

According to Marx (1930) class struggle is a product of the proletariat selling their labor power in return for wages. He states, however, that capitalism’s “internal tensions would lead to capitalism’s self-destruction and replacement by a new system referred to as socialism.” Zukerfeld (2017 p.162) states that “it is the history of capitalism (and of its classes) which explains these trends and not the other way around.” Though Marx predicted that the utopian society was coming very soon, maybe to see the best outcome as a reality a society must first go through a transformation so terribly frightening that it scares itself into this socialist society. I can see a current wave in western society for a socialist structure that takes care of the worker and those that can not work anymore or never could while still holding true to the values that created the freedoms they enjoy. If we ever needed a crisis or coming to reality with all that is wrong within a culture or society, we need look no further than the current political and social climate in the United States. Yet, even here I see an opportunity to grow into that better, more inclusive society Marx described and just maybe, this is that fall of capitalist alienation right in front of us. Unfortunately, I fear with so much information to take in about what is currently happening in America, that most of it is going right over our heads.


References

Apondaca, M. L., 1977. The Chicana Woman: An Historical Materialist Perspective. Latin American Perspectives Vol. 4, Women and Class Struggle pp. 70-89.

Marx, K. 1930. Capital. London Toronto. J. M. Dent & Sons, ltd

Wang, H. 1974. Concerning the Materialist Dialect. Philosophy East and West, Vol 24.3, pp. 30-319. University of Hawai’i Press.

Weber, M. 1922. Class, Status, Party. Economy and Society, University of California Press.

Woodward, H. 1979. Acquisition. Critical Inquiry, Vol. 6.2 pp. 291-303. The University of Chicago Press.

Zuckerfeld, M. 2017. Classes: A Theory from a Cognitive Materialist Perspective. Knowledge in the Age of Digital Capitalism: An Introduction to Cognitive Materialism. Pp. 161-178. London: University of Westminster Press.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

573-482-2718

1501 North Main Street Cape Girardeau, Cape Girardeau County 63701
USA

  • Tumblr

©2017 BY ADAM NELSON. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page