
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY: WHISTLEBLOWERS
In the aftermath of 9/11, we witnessed our country change from a state that policies to, in my opinion, an official police state. Street cameras weren't new things but the facial recognition software and collections of meta-data on people are. We have seen people attempt to bring attention to such things, to their own expense. From Thomas Drake to Edward Snowden blowing the whistle on domestic privacy concerns within the NSA and Federal government; to the likes of Chelsie Manning and Sibell Edmonds who show other forms of deceit to the American People by blowing the whistle on cover ups and down right murder in Manning's case.
We have had whistleblower protection laws in place, however, those laws do not completely protect intelligence community whistleblowers. The chain of command must be followed in order to have a board hear your complaint. What good does that do when the ones in the chain of command are the same people giving the orders that are viewed by the whistleblowers as unethical and in the cases, I am presenting, unconstitutional.

WHISTLEBLOWERS: THE SUPERHEROES OF TODAY'S TECHNOLOGY WORLD
4th of December 2015
Whistleblowers: The Superheroes of Today’s Technology World.
When we click “Agree” on a website’s privacy policy or terms of use agreement, most of us have little actual idea of what the language in the policy says due to its boring and often lengthy language. We could essentially be waiving all of our rights to privacy with one click. One recent example of this is when Instagram included in its policy that new terms of use suggested that, “the company could accept payment in exchange for the use of a person’s username, likeness, photos, and other data for sponsored content or promotions” (Ngak). If you didn’t pay close attention to this, and you use Instagram, you are subject to these terms. Examples like this show privacy protection that we, the consumer and general public have a choice about; but what about the times our privacy is violated without our knowledge and consent? Edward Snowden and other whistleblowers have tried to show us over the years that privacy and, in particular privacy in regards to the U.S. constitution, is something that is a human right. We should be able to communicate and explore information with little to no hindrance. Some people in high ranking government offices, and private sector upper-level officers don’t necessarily disagree with this view but do see the right to privacy as a difficulty
Nelson 2
for them. Marketing constraints to reach a particular consumer, or protection from a potential cyber or terrorist attack may justify this way of thinking. Whistleblowers are the heroes and villains of the new digital age of privacy. The difference of opinion depends on who you speak with. Lost in all of this is the importance of whistleblowers and the protections granted to them through the Whistleblower Protection Act or the (WPA), which is clearly in need of being updated to better reflect the world’s new use of technology.
According to the 2007 article released by the American Civil Liberties Union, “Disavowed: The Government’s Unchecked Retaliation Against National Security Whistleblowers” the Whistleblower Protection Act (WPA) was intended to “encourage government employees to step forward and disclose wrongdoing within their agencies” and that by doing so “they will promote good government, reduce government misconduct, and serve the important purpose of a more transparent government" (Goodman Et, al.). Sounds well and good right; however maybe not so much for the intelligence community. Under United States Code 5 U.S.C. § 2302(a)(2)(C)(ii)-(iii), “those working for the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), and National Security Agency (NSA) are not protected under the WPA.” The technology at our fingertips demands responsibility in regards to our personal information. If we allow people access to that information, such as those working for the NSA, and they see things that they believe to be morally or ethically wrong or inhumane, there should be a pathway with protection for anyone in any branch of government.
Nelson 3
This is where the Whistleblower Protection Act actually fails at its task. Those possessing the most vital information, are simply not protected by it.
In an effort to understand this law a little bit better, it was first enacted by congress as the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 (CSRA). According to this act “for the first time, a Federal statute created a legal mandate within the civil service to protect whistleblowers from reprisal and to act against those who initiate reprisal actions.” This act created the Office of Special Counsel (OSC) and placed it within the U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board." Furthermore, it stated that “In regards to whistleblower protections, the result of the CSRA is not what congress had hoped for due in particular to the OSC’s failure to protect whistleblowers by not bringing a single corrective action case since 1979 to the Merit Systems Protection Board on behalf of a whistleblower.”(U.S. MSPB p5). The passing of the WPA of 1989 soon followed to separate the OSC from the MSPB, and was again revised in 1994 to “clarify the
rules governing OSC disclosure of information about whistleblowers, while also allowing access for the whistleblower to obtain relevant evidence in the event that they bring their own cases to the MSPB.” The passage and amending of these laws clearly shows that even members of congress understand the importance of whistleblowers. With this being the case, why then since the explosion of technology has this act not once again been revised to better complement today’s more connected world?
The Government could take steps to, at the very least, allow a member of the
Nelson 4
intelligence community to have a comfortable and trusted outlet that would look into the witnessed wrongdoings, and justify whether or not to send this information to the U.S. Court of Appeals for review. Had proper protections been in place for whistleblowers so they would be fully aware that whatever information they divulged would not cost them prosecution, Snowden and Manning may have been more forthcoming with the information that troubled them. This in turn could have saved the United States Government a lot of embarrassment. By placing this information into the hands of those we vote to make decisions, rather than to leak it to the internet, you give our elected officials the chance to make a decision. They have the choice to alert the people of the wrongdoing or suffer the consequences of this going to the media. This protects sensitive information from getting into the wrong hands and gives whistleblowers confidence that the information they have witnessed will make a difference in the right hands. This would also show the American people that government officials are not scared to admit that they screwed up; which I would personally love to hear admitted for once.
The Revelations revealed by Edward Snowden regarding NSA spying, and the info released by Chelsea Manning that included documents describing our actions in the middle east shook the world in different ways. While Manning leaked information to the Website Wikileaks, Snowden chose a much different, and in my opinion, more professional path of leaking information. Manning’s leaks which were
known as the “Iraq and Afghanistan War Logs, showed a side to the U.S. war on terror that we,
Nelson 5
the public, had never been exposed to. They showed that war actions voted on and approved by the U.S. Government were possibly responsible for war crimes and that those actions resulted in civilian casualties. “She also transmitted a video of a U.S. Apache helicopter in Baghdad shown opening fire on civilian news crew members that the military thought were insurgents, whose camera was mistaken for an RPG” (Tate). This information is vital to the public because it shows that decisions made during war times can disregard civilian life while on the other hand it has damaged the United States government’s reputation with other world governments.
Reputation plays a great role in geopolitics, and damaging relationships can prove costly in many different ways. An example of this was the documentation that the NSA had been surveilling German Chancellor Angela Merkel. In the release of these documents, sensitive information such as names of agents in the field that were undercover in different parts of the world were released, immediately putting those people at risk and spoiling any plans or resolutions that were in the works. This mistrust has developed tension between the U.S and Germany that did not exist before the leaks. This could have been avoided with proper protection for all whistleblowers, not just ones covered in the current WPA.
In contrast to Manning’s divulging of information to the website WikiLeaks, “Edward Snowden chose a different, more proactive and secure route to protect certain individuals” (Greenwald). While Manning negligently released info to WikiLeaks putting undercover agents at risk, among other things; Snowden took this idea of protecting people while getting
Nelson 6
information out, and put it into practice by releasing this information to a renowned and trusted journalist in Glenn Greenwald. Former civil rights attorney and Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Glenn Greenwald met Snowden in Hong Kong in an effort to get Snowden's story out. By releasing the information this way Snowden assured himself that he had done the best thing possible, he knew of, with the information. Whistleblowers “ cannot share classified information with an attorney unless the attorney has a security clearance and the government thinks the attorney has a need to know the classified information” (Goodman Et, al p16). Snowden obviously could not go before the MSPB due to intelligence employees not being protected under the WPA, and did not feel that posting this information online was in line with his moral and ethical reasoning for releasing the information in the first place. He wanted to inform the country, and the world, with as little effect to human life as possible. Only time will tell the total implications of his leaks.
Most readers may think that the First Amendment protects everyone to free speech; however “The Supreme Court has held that the First Amendment rights of government employees are more limited than those of ordinary citizens.” (Goodman et, al). Regardless of all of the obstacles stacked against whistleblowers, both Republicans and Democrats feel the need for whistleblower protection. Rep. Christopher Shays, R-CT stated that “the use of expansive executive authority demands equally expansive scrutiny by Congress and the public. One absolute essential source of information to sustain that oversight is whistleblowers.”
Nelson 7
Another great point was brought up by Rep. Bruce Braley, D-IA stating “we need to send a strong message that protecting the rights of whistleblowers is not a Democratic issue, it is not a Republican issue, it is an issue that impacts the lives and the safety of every American Citizen” (Goodman et, al. p13). As you can see members of Congress on both sides of the isle are strongly for whistleblower protection, though the mainstream media may make it seem otherwise.
Although it is widely believed that whistleblower protection is essential to a free democracy, when it comes down to it certain government officials and high-ranking company officers, it seems that profits or political gain can be attributed to certain wrongdoings. After the BP oil spill, you may remember hearing that the inspections of the rigs were not being done as they should have been. In a report by Abbie Boudreau and David Fitzpatrick, “Whistleblower Says Poor Inspections Partly to
Blame for Spill” they show that “many of the inspectors of the gulf rigs joined the Minerals Management Service, who oversee inspections of the gulf oil rigs, from the oil industry and had relationships with people in the business.” They also stated that “inspectors got paid meals and tickets to sporting events from companies they monitored; let oil and gas company workers fill out their inspection forms in pencil, with the inspectors writing over those entries in ink before turning them in; and in 2008, one conducted inspections of four offshore platforms while negotiating a job with the company that operated them” (Boudreau et, al.). This blatant
Nelson 8
disrespect for regulation, the environment, and personal lives shows that even though whistleblower protection exists, corporations and politicians in all facets of the government have a distinct reason to not want someone to blow the whistle on them or their company. It could cost them significant amounts of money, and hit them with a blow to their reputation.
In regards to our rights under the constitution and bill of rights, “certain programs at work at the NSA such as Prism, Mainway, Bullrun, X-Keyscore, and Tracfin, collect different types of information from the American People. (Scherer et, al. p15)” In Glenn Greenwald’s recent book “No Place to Hide, Edward Snowden, The NSA, and the U.S. Surveillance State” he describes the previous programs, and discusses them in depth with Snowden. Mike Rogers, whom according to NSA.gov is the Commander, U.S. Cyber command and Director National Security Agency/Chief, Central Security Service, is a skeptic of certain claims made by Snowden. One of those claims is in regards to the program, X-Keyscore. Snowden made the claim: “I, sitting at my desk, could wire-tap anyone, from you or your accountant, to a federal judge or even the President, if I had a personal email.” Rogers accused Snowden of lying about this saying “it’s impossible for him to do what he was saying he could do.” (Greenwald p157). According to Greenwald's Book,
The program does indeed let an analyst search for all emails that include targeted users in the “cc” line or mention of them in the body of the text. One of X-Keyscore’s most
Nelson 9
valuable functions to the NSA is its ability to surveil the activities on online social networks, such as Facebook and Twitter, which the agency believes will provide a wealth of information and “insight into the personal lives of targets. An analyst enters the desired user name on Facebook, along with the date range of activity, and X-Keyscore then returns all of that user’s information, including messages, chats, and other private postings.
This program is in direct violation of the Fourth Amendment which states on Cornell University Law School’s website:
The right of the people to be secure in their person, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
As you see even with probable cause, a warrant is still needed in order to conduct a lawful search.
Even with the WPA, and the Fourth Amendment, those who blew the whistle on certain programs have seen their rights as Americans vanish. Edward Snowden, and Chelsea Manning, though by their own choice, will never lead a normal life like you and I know again. There is a view that whistleblowers provide a civil service to the nation and the world. That view,
Nelson 10
however, is not supported by some; many of which are in powerful positions be it in the government or private sector, whose livelihoods are determined on certain information that doesn’t find its way to the press or even worse to the public. In order to provide a greater civil service to the people of the world, whistleblowers are of vital importance and we should really take a look at the WPA to see if there is a better way for whistleblowers to divulge their information without fear of prosecution. With this better protection, governments and corporations will be responsible for releasing this information as ethically, and morally
responsible as possible. By doing these things, we will eventually begin to see certain acts of violence or negligence dissipate while accountability and respect for human rights could soar. I thank the people brave enough to step out of the shadow and into the light if they believe it makes the world a better place. In other aspects, I have witnessed greed first hand, and quoting a favorite movie for a lot of people in my generation The Dark Knight: “Some people just want to watch the world burn.” In one of the final scenes, it is shown what it would look like on a screen to tap into each person’s cell phone. To most this was the culminating moment of the movie, while, to me, it was one of the scariest and most real aspects of the film. What we saw in that film, and what we now know, should make us all question whether our right to privacy, is worth it. France is currently mourning the deaths following recent attacks, while “being one of the most surveilled countries in the world” (Amnesty Int). This should go to show the importance of privacy, and whistleblowers more than ever before. When the authority of power
Nelson 11
is being misused, and of no benefit to the general public, who truly benefits in the end? We must re-work the Whistleblower Protection Act to better serve the needs of a nation, instead of the needs of the few. We must also keep information free and flowing to allow, not only equality, but also accountability to always be within the fingertips of today’s technology superheroes.
Works Cited
Ngak, Chenda “Should you be Concerned about Instagram’s New Privacy Policy?” CBS News, 28 December 2012. Web
Goodman, Melissa. Crump, Catherine. Corris, Sara. “Disavowed: The Government’s Unchecked Retaliation Against National Security Whistleblowers” ACLU. 2007 Web
United States. U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB). Office of Policy and Evaluation “Whistleblower Protections for Federal Employees: Report to the President and the Congress of the United States”. Washington: GPO, 2010. Print.
Nelson 12
Tate, Julie “Bradley Manning Sentenced to 35 years in WikiLeaks Case” The Washington Post. 21 August 2013. Web
Greenwald, Glenn. “No Place to Hide, Edward Snowden, The NSA, and the U.S. Surveillance State”. New York, New York: Metropolitan Books Henry Holt and Company, LLC, 2014. Print.
Scherer, Michael. Shuster, Simon. “Number Two Edward Snowden The Dark Prophet” Time. 23 December 2013 Print
Cornell University Law School, “Fourth Amendment” U.S. Constitution. Cornell University
Greenwald, Glenn “Edward Snowden: The Whistleblower Behind the NSA Surveillance Revelations” The Guardian, The NSA Files. 11 June 2013. Web
Boudreau, Abbie. Fitzpatrick, David “Whistleblower Says Poor Inspections Partly to Blame for Spill” CNN News, CNN Special Investigations Unit, 9 June 2010, Web
Amnesty International, “France: New Surveillance Law a Major Blow to Human Rights” Amnesty International, 24 July 2015, Web
Faces of the Heroes
Whistleblowers: The Superheroes of Today's Technology World
Patriotic Criminals: Whistleblowers vs. Big Brother

Former FBI Translator. Post 9/11 whistleblower regarding flawed translations and revealed failures throughout the F.B.I. Founder of National Security Whistleblower Coalition.

Former NSA Senior Executive. Blew the whistle on "Trailblazer" project. Refused to take a plea deal, finally found guilty of a misdemeanor for exceeding authorized use of a computer. 10 of 11 charges against him were finally dropped.

Former Private First Class U.S. Army. Leaked classified documents to WikiLeaks in 2010. Sentenced to 35 years imprisonment. Sentence commuted by President Obama in January 2017. Over 400,000 Iraq war documents and 90,000 Afghan war documents. Infamous "Collateral Damage Video". https://collateralmurder.wikileaks.org/

Former U.S. Military and NSA Contractor. Whistleblower Regarding breech of Privacy by the U.S. Government and its Intelligence community. Leaked documents to Award Winning Journalist Glenn Greenwald and documentary filmmaker Laura Poitras. Living under Asylum in Russia with his Wife.

Snowden Talks with Award Winning Journalist Glenn Greenwald. Picture taken in Hong Kong when Snowden was fleeing the U.S.

















![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Page includes articles written by me, about the whistle blower protection act, and whistle blowers during the digital age.
In the aftermath of 9/11, we witnessed our country change from a state that polices to, in my opinion, an official police state. Street cameras weren't new things but the facial recognition software and collections of meta-data on people are. We have seen people attempt to bring attention to such things, to their own expense. From Thomas Drake to Edward Snowden blowing the whistle on domestic privacy concerns within the NSA and Federal government; to the likes of Chelsie Manning and Sibell Edmonds who show other forms of protest to the American People by blowing the whistle on cover ups and down right murder in Manning's case.
We have had whistle blower protection laws in place, however, those laws do not completely protect intelligence community whistle blowers. The chain of command must be followed in order to have a board hear your complaint. What good does that do when the ones in the chain of command are the same people giving the orders that are viewed by the whistle blowers as unethical and in the cases, I am presenting, unconstitutional.
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|
A brief overview of some pictures and a spreadsheet of items I consume and brands associated with the items.
There is definitely a trend for Organic things such as my Milk and Maple Syrup all while I still wonder if they are actually organic or just finding a way to use it as a new selling point. Tom's of Maine Deodorant, and Toothpaste were a good Idea until I watched John Oliver on HBO yesterday and found out they are owned now by Colgate-Palmolive. Realistically the only thing's that I am confident on their creation and distribution are the beers by 4-Hands Brewery out of St. Louis Missouri which could be something that ties into my cultural identity as I am trying to find a good local brew to support and enjoy. I try to limit waste and eat all of what I purchase though I'm not always good at it as you can see by the piled up cheezes. I do not think that a lot of people follow the same trend as I do. I am a non-traditional college student that has to scrape by compared to many of my friends, whom of which are married with careers; well, most of them.
Overall I feel that my eating habits consist of still too much fast food because, though I have plenty of complimentary cooking items, things such as fresh beef or chicken are lacking. Frozen Chicken breasts, however, allow for my consistent chicken and broccoli with fried rice. What can I say, It's my ramen.
Click on photo for inventory information
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
![]() |
Cape Girardeau MO.
19th October 2017
Research Proposal: Removal of the Cape Girardeau Confederate States of America Monument
Updated December of 2022: The memorial has been removed and taken to the Civil War Memorial at Barracks Park in St. Louis Missouri.
For my research question I am going to try to focus on Confederate state statues, such as the one in downtown cape, and propose that the majority of the community would agree that it should be removed from the public courthouse grounds. This has been a hot topic in the national media for the past couple of years, and even more so with the new administration in the white house and congress. I feel that people in Missouri, compared to those in South Carolina or Virginia where there has been much conflict over this issue, will rise up and show that the majority of the population would be for the removal of the C.S.A. monument on Lorimar Street in downtown Cape Girardeau.
This research would be able to build upon what we are seeing in the United States as a movement to not just destroy our history and move on, but to get a sense for where items such as this monument should be displayed. With the social movements this country has seen since the Civil Rights Movement I am certain that research exists regarding the livelihoods of members of the African American community and their feelings towards monuments of this type. What I am curious to discover is exactly how many generalized questionnaires or surveys have been proposed to members of the white community in areas with these monuments.
Evidence that would need to be collected would be from a well-designed questionnaire to answer the question of; What would the response to the questionnaire, would it be an overwhelming response for one way or another, or would we fall into an area where the margin of error is too close to gather a true answer. A survey would be something that would work in this regard because I would be able to stand near the statue and ask questions, and potentially be able to submit that questionnaire to members of local government and also members of the downtown community that work and shop there on a regular basis.
For my training an preparedness I have gone through the Citi certification which has helped me gain a better understanding of whom might be able to participate in my research, and how many people would be needed to gather a true opinion of the community and it's feelings towards the C.S.A. monument and its removal. I have not done any work currently on this project, though I have followed National news stories that show a growing number of people protesting to have these types of monuments removed. I will also look back in history at other civilizations and governments and attempt to compare things such as the holocaust or the apartheid to find similar instances where other governments throughout history have made the decision to move, once prominent and glorified monuments or public figure statues, to a museum instead of on public land for all to see.
My project will show that in a typically Republican voting state in recent elections, that the will of the people will still show that anything resembling slavery or the old south should be removed and put into a museum, though I don't anticipate this will be an overwhelming agreement amongst community members. This will pave a path for other communities and states to approach its citizens and show quantitative and qualitative evidence that support for
removal of C.S.A. monuments should be removed and placed into history museums instead of on public land such as court houses and other government buildings.











