top of page
Search

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Middle Management Bonus Structure

Writer: adam nelson
adam nelson
Dec 7, 2022
8 min read

Within the hospitality industry there are an array of pay scales and bonus structures from the top executive down through middle management all the way to frontline staff. My focus is to argue the pros and cons of bonus structures mainly within middle management for hotels, restaurants, and retail by focusing on three common bonus structures across the board: high sales, low cost or low labor percentages, and high retention. I will include my own firsthand experiences, as well as my fiancé’s, and I will build upon them with referenced research to show each side to these bonuses along with the ethical expectations that come with the handling or mishandling of the bonus structures. We will also see the incentivized effect to hit performance numbers that at times prove unattainable when you wish to deliver top notch quality and safety. This proves true throughout all areas of the hospitality industry within the U.S. and throughout the world using these bonus structures.

When we look at the pros of management bonuses, we expect to see managers with a higher drive to perform at a level set by the company to earn a compensation bonus of some type. One reason for these bonuses could be for higher overall sales or focusing on higher sales in a specific category compared to the previous quarter or year. Other reasons for management bonuses could include meeting or beating projected numbers between multiple types of operating costs, hiring and retaining quality staff, or comparing performances between managers or stores during a set time period.

A company could use one or more reward type to incentivize their managers to do a task or reach specific performance numbers. In the past, I personally have received cash, bonuses on paychecks, gift cards, merchandise, paid time off, event tickets, and other work benefits such as receiving a requested day off above another manager that requested the same time. Companies can personalize other rewards as well to push managers towards achieving goals. Bigger companies also have the ability to reward with company stock, a paid vacation, or a percentage of sales bonus.

First, I wanted to talk about the bonus structure I found to be most beneficial to a company and to its staff. The retention bonus has shown effectiveness in not only retaining employees but also highlights the importance of proper training and following up using performance evaluations. If we gain an understanding of where incentives can go wrong, we can “create incentive programs that meet the needs of both parties fairly” (Milano, 2022). When a business values a manager applying the STEM Process first, then they will not only retain important employees but also save large amounts money they would have spent on repeat hiring or potential errors and liabilities due to insufficient training. By retaining employees as they continuously gain experience, there is a better chance for naturally improving other performance numbers. Employees that feel confident and safe in their work will show increased morale and therefore workflow. The manager that takes the time to create an effective quality staff will have to spend less time and money fixing problems.

The downside to retention bonuses when applied to management could mean a manager does not terminate or effectively deal with a bad employee while trying to keep their short-term retention bonus. A “bad” employee around could make for an unsafe environment or poor morale. Good managers know for long-term interests if they do not properly oversee bad employees, which could occasionally need termination, then better employees will either lower their standards or leave. A good employee could instead replace a bad employee taking up space. The downside to retention bonuses when applied to ownership could mean an owner inappropriately pressures management to never fire, so their unemployment rates and insurance rates do not rise. While some employees can be forced to change departments, go through additional training, or experience reduced hours, good business must see the unfortune possibility that some employee circumstances will merit immediate termination.

When considering the pros for examining labor costs, managers should, yet again, take time to properly train employees and lead by example. A single well-trained employee can be far more efficient and still comfortable performing over three employees that are so bad off that grouped together still do not know what is on a specific sandwich, cannot read a kitchen ticket, and cannot remember where the medium soda lids are stocked. In addition, if for example Monday night shifts are always dead, that would be a good shift to adjust labor and schedule lighter. As front of house closing manager, I was always told to keep labor percentages under 25 percent and shoot for 20 percent. My GM, Paige, never penalized me for higher percentages, but rarely was high labor an issue at Burrito-Ville.

A local example when more attention to labor numbers would not hurt would be Popeyes. Every time I go into Popeyes I see fifteen unmotivated employees, all bumping into each other with no clear assigned station, while another two employees do circles around all of them to keep that place afloat. I see the same girl every time I am there, working every station by herself. In less than ten minutes, she will go drop chicken in the fryer, run up to take an in-person order, go see warmers unstocked, go drop chicken in another fryer, take more orders, pull the first round of chicken, box a few whole tickets, take food out to a car, cash out the drive through and hand them their food, go back for the second round of chicken, box multiple whole tickets, get food to more customers, and back to cash out the drive through. Everyone else looks at each other as if it is everyone else’s first day in training, needing constant direction to be able to help. I could see the manager on duty playing on their phone in the office with the door cracked. I feel bad when I give her my order, and I feel worried when I do not see her on shift. During a rush, I bet eight effectively trained and managed employees would completely change that location. A manager could cut half the staff, retrain everyone, assign specific stations, give everyone left a raise, and still save labor costs.

A clear downside to low operation cost bonuses that every frontline staff member in the industry has suffered through countless times is operating short staffed. Just because everyone brought their A game, worked magic together, and kicked butt for a super chaotic shift that one time after a father and son employee combo called in sick does not mean that same shift in the future should automatically have two less employees scheduled every time. A bad manager tries to over manage labor costs in order to get their bonus, while often going home at the worst time to not even be there to deal with it themselves. Another downside is the safety risk of being improperly staffed. Examples of this could be employees in kitchens taking on too many tasks and putting themselves at risk of injury or potentially putting a guest at risk by not having proper security on staff. To cut costs a bad manager ma“might slash advertising, order cheaper materials, force subordinates to work more hours or delay equipment repairs”(Milano, 2022).

Finally, we look at sales bonuses in the hospitality industry and what impact they can have on employees and customers. The immediate thought is that sales goals will drive higher profits and with those profits a percentage could go to managers throughout the company that hit their personal goals. They would receive the bonus for those sales increases, and that would be clearly seen. What is not always seen, however, is what goes on to reach those sales numbers. Are the sales employees being too pushy, causing some customers to look elsewhere for service the next time? This could reflect in a five- or ten-year outlook if that trend continued unchecked. Are the sales numbers more important than your team’s health and safety as a manager. If you hit your sales goal, but had to pay employees overtime to receive the bonus, are you really benefiting the company? I’m sure some of the employees would love the overtime, however in the hospitality industry salaries are setup to avoid paying overtime. These are only a couple of questions to think about regarding the cons of a sales bonus for middle management. Increasing guests each year in a hotel along with sales numbers is a trend that shows positive on both sides, what if all of a sudden, the prices are raised to hit sales, and they aren’t raised properly to scale, and a competitor moves in and takes some of that previous business causing a down year. Managers have a lot on their shoulders in the first place, so again, is this benefiting the company, and the employee or just one or the other?

Managers are responsible for scheduling, ordering, managing inventory, hiring, training, retaining relationships with customers and the community, doing payroll, overseeing the staff and production during the actual business operations, and so many other unique tasks that consume their time. Managing all the responsibilities is demanding work and can be stressful enough without a potential boss aggressively riding them about hitting the numbers. Unbalanced bonus structures do harm to everyone involved. In addition, achieving a desired performance number does not mean problems in that field gone. Evaluating numbers cannot be the only way a company checks on how managers are performing. There are too many small and large unethical short term “fixes” that can be done to meet numbers. There is a lot of unethical

What we do not want is an ownership that rides their management too harshly to meet certain numbers without exceptions. This type of ownership leads a manager to pass this stress onto frontline staff to not mess up! to refuse to spend extra potential labor costs towards time needed to continuously train or be in attendance when needing to set the right example, and then refuse to remove a reoccurring threat to the overall company. A short-term goal would be more likely to motivate a lazy manager to make short term decisions that would benefit the manager and not company’s interest.

Another thing to highlight is the tole hyper focusing on numbers can take on management and staff morale. Staff pushed to take on extra work and stretched thin to attain these bonuses may never see a bonus at all. However, ownership or higher management is quick to say bonuses are always attainable if you ‘hit your numbers’ though. Which theoretically, it sounds simple, but unfortunately depends on the company you work for and how those bonus structures shape decisions in real time daily.

I would argue to pay higher base salaries and focus on training in hopes of higher morale with a smaller bonus structure that is not so much relied upon, as it is nice to get occasionally.

Conclusion:

An adequate system of training, setting expectations and goals early, and delivering bonuses that compensate as a compliment to your paycheck instead of something the employee relies upon can help to create a culture of good habits, high profits, and happy employers and employees. An inadequate system of these things has shown time after time for me personally, and in other accounts how a focus on bonuses and needing to earn more money in any possible way can be detrimental to a business and its employees. By focusing on retention and training, and paying a living wage we can assure that bonuses are exactly that, a bonus. We’re also assuring that bonuses are not something people have to rely upon because as we know, unless handled properly they can lead to poor morale, jealousy, resentment, and overall poor performance.



References

Milano, S. (2022, September 20). The Disadvantages of Manager Bonuses in Companies. Hearst

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

573-482-2718

1501 North Main Street Cape Girardeau, Cape Girardeau County 63701
USA

  • Tumblr

©2017 BY ADAM NELSON. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page